A healthy child goes to sleep and does not wake up, and no cause is ever found. It is rare, it is barely understood, and almost nobody has heard of it until it happens to them.
To say February 4, 2023 changed things for us is a gross understatement. It was that morning that I learned my beloved son had passed away at 15 years old in his sleep. There was no immediate cause of death — all of the usual suspects, and then some, being ruled out.
The official cause of death on the death certificate was "arrhythmia of unknown origin," ICD code I49.9. In 2023, Joel was one of 11 between the ages of 10 and 15 with this cause of death.
The assumption is that his heart just stopped working during his sleep — some misfiring that caused it to stop. There is really no way to tell. In reality, Joel's case is one of SUDC: Sudden Unexplained Death in Childhood.
There is not really a good way to know for sure the true number of unexplained deaths, because states and counties have different laws that govern autopsies. In Virginia, the law requires
"a medical examiner to determine the cause and manner of death of persons who die under specific circumstances."
Virginia Department of HealthSo in some places, medical examiners can't close an autopsy if the cause of death is unknown. Regardless, sometimes finding out the cause is well outside of their capabilities or capacity.
Since 2023, we have been working with Boston Children's Hospital's Robert's Program on Sudden Unexpected Death in Pediatrics and the SUDC Foundation in an effort to find a true cause for Joel's death.
The research process is complex. It takes incredibly experienced health professionals and researchers to look through an entire family health history, sequence multiple whole genomes, and pore through a significant amount of medical research.
In these rare cases, grief support extends to helping families navigate the research process itself. Families who want to go down this road must make critical decisions before arrangements can even be made. The decision to bank DNA has to be made almost immediately — blood samples must be taken and stored in specific ways to preserve it. That is only the first step. What follows is a highly complex and expensive process requiring experts and very complex genetic testing.
So this is where we are today. We believe that working with the Robert's Program, we might ultimately find a plausible cause. But until then, we wait, as we have done since 2023.
Fortunately or unfortunately, we've learned quite a bit in this process. Having obtained this wisdom, we feel a duty to support others who might be facing similar situations. Finding a cause of death is important, not just because we want to know, but because our girls might be at risk, and their future children, and extended family. Ultimately, for the sake of science, I feel bound — because it might help someone else.
"Research is creating new knowledge."
Neil ArmstrongIf you are reading this and finding yourself in the same situation, I am so sorry for your loss. We are here for you. Do not hesitate to contact us — but most importantly, contact the Robert's Program or the SUDC Foundation. Do not hesitate. It is very difficult making these kinds of decisions in the fog of this immense grief.
Boston Children's Hospital's program on Sudden Unexpected Death in Pediatrics. Investigates causes and works directly with families.
childrenshospital.orgSupport for families, advocacy, and funding for research into sudden unexplained death in childhood.
sudc.orgThe research, registries, and advocacy working to explain why a healthy child or teenager dies without warning — and the organizations that stay with the families left behind. Not the first week, when everyone comes. The long after, when they don't.
Because goodness is contagious.
The Let Goodness Shine Foundation is a donor-advised fund of the Arlington Community Foundation — a 501(c)(3) public charity, tax-exempt since March 1, 1992, and accredited under Community Foundations National Standards. EIN 54-1602838
Gifts are made to ACF for the benefit of the Joel Byrne Let Goodness Shine Fund. ACF issues your tax receipt and holds legal control over contributed assets. Contributions are deductible to the fullest extent allowed by law. We pay no salaries.
By check — payable to Arlington Community Foundation, with Joel Byrne Let Goodness Shine Fund on the memo line: 1100 N Glebe Rd, Suite 630, Arlington, VA 22201 · 703-243-4785